It still doesn't smell bad which is not what I expected from leaving raw milk on the counter for almost 5 days!
I dumped it down the drain, just to be on the safe side. I 'started' a new batch with the warm milk that we brought in from the barn this morning.
Hopefully this time it will work.
If it does, I'll look around for a great looking stoneware crock for the milk to clabber in!